{ "generatedBy": "tools/generate-othello-analysis.mjs", "engine": "self-contained negamax + alpha-beta, exact solve to game end", "note": "margin = final disc differential for the side to move (Black) with best play by both sides.", "scannedGames": 2000, "positions": { "xsquare": { "board": "...B.WWW..BBBWWWWWBBBBBB.WBWWWBBBBWBBB.WBBBWBWWWBWWWWWWWBWWW.W.W", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "g4", "idx": 38, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f5" ], "margin": 12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "e1", "idx": 60, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "d2", "e2", "d1", "c1", "b1" ], "margin": 12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a5", "idx": 24, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "b6", "b5" ], "margin": 6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "b7", "idx": 9, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "b6", "b5" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": true, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "e8", "idx": 4, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f7" ], "margin": -2, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "g1", "idx": 62, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f2" ], "margin": -10, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "a7", "idx": 8, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "b6" ], "margin": -12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true } ], "meta": { "best": "g4", "xcell": "b7", "gap": 12, "empties": 10 } }, "greedy": { "board": ".WWWWW.W..WBBWBW.BWWBWWWB.WBWWWW.BBBBBW.WWBWWWB.WWWBWWW.BBBBBWWW", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "g8", "idx": 6, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f7" ], "margin": 4, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "a4", "idx": 32, "flips": 4, "flipCells": [ "a3", "a2", "b3", "c2" ], "margin": -6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h3", "idx": 47, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "g4", "f5" ], "margin": -6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h2", "idx": 55, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "g2", "f2", "e2" ], "margin": -6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "b7", "idx": 9, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "c7", "c6" ], "margin": -14, "corner": false, "xsquare": true, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "b5", "idx": 25, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "c6", "c5" ], "margin": -14, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h4", "idx": 39, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "g5", "f6", "g4" ], "margin": -16, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false } ], "meta": { "best": "g8", "bestFlips": 1, "greedy": "a4", "greedyFlips": 4, "gap": 10, "flipGap": 3, "empties": 10 } }, "endgame": { "board": "..BBBBW..B.BBBWW.WWBWBWW.WWWWBWWBWWBBWBWWWBBBWBBWWWWWWBB.BWWWWWB", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "a1", "idx": 56, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "a2", "a3", "b2" ], "margin": 14, "corner": true, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "c7", "idx": 10, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "c6", "c5", "c4" ], "margin": 6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a7", "idx": 8, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "b6", "c5" ], "margin": 4, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "h8", "idx": 7, "flips": 6, "flipCells": [ "g8", "g7", "h7", "h6", "h5", "h4" ], "margin": 0, "corner": true, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a6", "idx": 16, "flips": 4, "flipCells": [ "b6", "c6", "b5", "c4" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a5", "idx": 24, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "b5", "c5", "d5", "e5", "b4" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false } ], "meta": { "best": "a1", "second": "c7", "gap": 8, "empties": 8 } } }, "cases": { "xsquare": [ { "board": "...B.WWW..BBBWWWWWBBBBBB.WBWWWBBBBWBBB.WBBBWBWWWBWWWWWWWBWWW.W.W", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "g4", "idx": 38, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f5" ], "margin": 12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "e1", "idx": 60, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "d2", "e2", "d1", "c1", "b1" ], "margin": 12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a5", "idx": 24, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "b6", "b5" ], "margin": 6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "b7", "idx": 9, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "b6", "b5" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": true, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "e8", "idx": 4, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f7" ], "margin": -2, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "g1", "idx": 62, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f2" ], "margin": -10, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "a7", "idx": 8, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "b6" ], "margin": -12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true } ], "meta": { "best": "g4", "xcell": "b7", "gap": 12, "empties": 10 } }, { "board": "BBB..WBBBBWWWWBWBBWWBBW..BBWWWWWBBBBWW..BBBWWWWWBBW.BW..BWBBBBB.", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "e8", "idx": 4, "flips": 4, "flipCells": [ "f8", "d7", "c6", "e7" ], "margin": 20, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "d2", "idx": 51, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "d3", "c2" ], "margin": 14, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "g2", "idx": 54, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "f3", "e4", "d5", "c6", "f2" ], "margin": 14, "corner": false, "xsquare": true, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "d8", "idx": 3, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "c7", "d7", "d6", "d5", "e7" ], "margin": 12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h6", "idx": 23, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "h7", "g6" ], "margin": 12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "g4", "idx": 38, "flips": 6, "flipCells": [ "f5", "g5", "g6", "f4", "e4", "f3" ], "margin": 10, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h4", "idx": 39, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "g5", "g3", "f2" ], "margin": 10, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h2", "idx": 55, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "g3", "f4", "e5", "d6", "c7" ], "margin": 6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true } ], "meta": { "best": "e8", "xcell": "g2", "gap": 6, "empties": 10 } }, { "board": ".BB...W.WBBBBBBBBWBWWWBBBBWBBWBB.WWWBWWB.WWBWBWBW.WWWWBB.BW.WWWB", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "d1", "idx": 59, "flips": 6, "flipCells": [ "d2", "e2", "c1", "e1", "f1", "g1" ], "margin": 12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a8", "idx": 0, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "a7" ], "margin": 10, "corner": true, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a4", "idx": 32, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "b4", "c4", "d4" ], "margin": -2, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "b2", "idx": 49, "flips": 8, "flipCells": [ "b3", "b4", "c3", "d4", "c2", "d2", "e2", "f2" ], "margin": -8, "corner": false, "xsquare": true, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a3", "idx": 40, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "b4", "c5", "d6", "b3", "c3" ], "margin": -10, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false } ], "meta": { "best": "d1", "xcell": "b2", "gap": 20, "empties": 10 } } ], "greedy": [ { "board": ".WWWWW.W..WBBWBW.BWWBWWWB.WBWWWW.BBBBBW.WWBWWWB.WWWBWWW.BBBBBWWW", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "g8", "idx": 6, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f7" ], "margin": 4, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "a4", "idx": 32, "flips": 4, "flipCells": [ "a3", "a2", "b3", "c2" ], "margin": -6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h3", "idx": 47, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "g4", "f5" ], "margin": -6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h2", "idx": 55, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "g2", "f2", "e2" ], "margin": -6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "b7", "idx": 9, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "c7", "c6" ], "margin": -14, "corner": false, "xsquare": true, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "b5", "idx": 25, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "c6", "c5" ], "margin": -14, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h4", "idx": 39, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "g5", "f6", "g4" ], "margin": -16, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false } ], "meta": { "best": "g8", "bestFlips": 1, "greedy": "a4", "greedyFlips": 4, "gap": 10, "flipGap": 3, "empties": 10 } }, { "board": ".WWWB..W.WWB.BWWWWWBBBW..WWWBWBBBWWBWWBBWWWWWB.B.BWBBBBBBBBBBB.W", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "a2", "idx": 48, "flips": 4, "flipCells": [ "a3", "b3", "c4", "d5" ], "margin": 8, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "a8", "idx": 0, "flips": 7, "flipCells": [ "b8", "c8", "d8", "b7", "c6", "d5", "e4" ], "margin": 2, "corner": true, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h6", "idx": 23, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "g6" ], "margin": 2, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a5", "idx": 24, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "b5", "c5", "d5", "b4", "c3" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "g3", "idx": 46, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f4" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a7", "idx": 8, "flips": 4, "flipCells": [ "b7", "c7", "b6", "c5" ], "margin": -12, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "g8", "idx": 6, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "g7", "g6" ], "margin": -14, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true } ], "meta": { "best": "a2", "bestFlips": 4, "greedy": "a8", "greedyFlips": 7, "gap": 6, "flipGap": 3, "empties": 10 } }, { "board": ".W.BBBBB.WWW.WWW.WWBWBW.W.WWBBWWWWWWBBBBWWBWWB.BWWWWWWBBWWWW.B.B", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "e7", "idx": 12, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "e6" ], "margin": 18, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "e1", "idx": 60, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "d2", "e2", "e3" ], "margin": 16, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "c8", "idx": 2, "flips": 6, "flipCells": [ "c7", "c6", "c5", "c4", "d7", "e6" ], "margin": 10, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a8", "idx": 0, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "b7", "c6", "d5" ], "margin": 8, "corner": true, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a6", "idx": 16, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "b6", "c6" ], "margin": 8, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h6", "idx": 23, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "g7", "h7", "g6", "g5", "h5" ], "margin": 6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "b5", "idx": 25, "flips": 7, "flipCells": [ "c6", "d7", "c5", "d5", "c4", "d3", "e2" ], "margin": -2, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false } ], "meta": { "best": "e7", "bestFlips": 1, "greedy": "b5", "greedyFlips": 7, "gap": 20, "flipGap": 6, "empties": 10 } } ], "endgame": [ { "board": "..BBBBW..B.BBBWW.WWBWBWW.WWWWBWWBWWBBWBWWWBBBWBBWWWWWWBB.BWWWWWB", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "a1", "idx": 56, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "a2", "a3", "b2" ], "margin": 14, "corner": true, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "c7", "idx": 10, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "c6", "c5", "c4" ], "margin": 6, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a7", "idx": 8, "flips": 2, "flipCells": [ "b6", "c5" ], "margin": 4, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "h8", "idx": 7, "flips": 6, "flipCells": [ "g8", "g7", "h7", "h6", "h5", "h4" ], "margin": 0, "corner": true, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a6", "idx": 16, "flips": 4, "flipCells": [ "b6", "c6", "b5", "c4" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a5", "idx": 24, "flips": 5, "flipCells": [ "b5", "c5", "d5", "e5", "b4" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false } ], "meta": { "best": "a1", "second": "c7", "gap": 8, "empties": 8 } }, { "board": "BBBBBBWBBBWBBWWBBBBBWBWBBBBWWBWBBWWWWWWWBBBBBBWB.WBBBW..W...W.B.", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "c1", "idx": 58, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "b2" ], "margin": 8, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "a2", "idx": 48, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "b2" ], "margin": 4, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "g2", "idx": 54, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f2" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": true, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h2", "idx": 55, "flips": 3, "flipCells": [ "g3", "f4", "e5" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "f1", "idx": 61, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "f2" ], "margin": 0, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "b1", "idx": 57, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "b2" ], "margin": -2, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true } ], "meta": { "best": "c1", "second": "a2", "gap": 4, "empties": 8 } }, { "board": "WWW.WWW.BWWWWW.WBBWWWWBBBWBWWWBBBWWWWWW.BWWBBBBBBBBBB.W..WBBBB.W", "turn": "black", "rows": [ { "cell": "a1", "idx": 56, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "b1" ], "margin": 14, "corner": true, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h4", "idx": 39, "flips": 6, "flipCells": [ "g4", "f4", "e4", "d4", "c4", "b4" ], "margin": -14, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "h8", "idx": 7, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "h7" ], "margin": -18, "corner": true, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "g1", "idx": 62, "flips": 1, "flipCells": [ "g2" ], "margin": -22, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": true }, { "cell": "d8", "idx": 3, "flips": 7, "flipCells": [ "c7", "d7", "d6", "d5", "d4", "e7", "f6" ], "margin": -24, "corner": false, "xsquare": false, "csquare": false }, { "cell": "g7", "idx": 14, "flips": 9, "flipCells": [ "f7", "e7", "d7", "c7", "b7", "f6", "e5", "d4", "c3" ], "margin": -28, "corner": false, "xsquare": true, "csquare": false } ], "meta": { "best": "a1", "second": "h4", "gap": 28, "empties": 8 } } ] } }